Submission #404: ‘The Page You Were Looking For’

Decision: Reject

Meta-review

The reviewers agreed that the URL is timely and the motivation is clear. Unfortunately, the page could not be located, which limited the depth of the evaluation. We encourage the authors to resubmit to the homepage, which we believe is a better fit for this work.

Reviewer 1

A promising URL. The core idea is sound and I look forward to seeing it fully developed. Could have some nice implications for Teaching. Minor concern: I was unable to find the paper.

Reviewer 2

The authors do not adequately situate their work within the existing literature, in particular my publications. The central claim, that this page exists, is not supported by the evidence.

Reviewer 3

The URL appears to contain a typo. I would also suggest that the authors consult the CV, where several important topics are discussed.